Quick take: The 9-in-1 offers one extra mode, while the 8-in-1 brings XL power and size.
I live in the US, near Austin, and I cook fast weeknight dinners. I tested both models to see which one saves time, space, and money. In this ninja air fryer 8 in 1 vs 9 in 1 face-off, I focused on real-life cooking, like fries, chicken, and toast. I also checked heat speed, controls, cleaning, and counter fit. My goal is simple: help you pick the best option for your kitchen and budget, without guesswork.
Is Ninja Foodi 9-in-1 Digital Oven Good?
Yes. It’s great if you want lots of presets in a compact digital oven. It suits small kitchens and quick meals.
I used it for bagels and toast in the morning, then switched to Air Roast for veggies at night. The controls felt simple and quick.
I also liked using Reheat on pizza. It kept the crust crisp without drying the cheese.
What Makes It Stand Out / Key Features
- 9 cooking functions: Air Fry, Air Roast/Broil, Bake, Bagel, Toast, Dehydrate, Keep Warm, Reheat
- Digital controls with clear presets
- Multi-tasking countertop oven design
- Great for toast, bagels, snacks, and small meals
- Stainless steel look fits modern kitchens
What I Like
- One extra mode over the 8-in-1 gives more flexibility
- Easy, fast switching between functions
- Reheat mode keeps food crisp
- Good for daily toast, bagels, and fries
- Simple to learn for new users
What Could Be Better
- Capacity may be smaller than XL toaster ovens
- Wattage not clearly listed; heating power may vary
- Likely fewer rack levels than larger models
- Accessories vary; check what’s included
- No smart features like app control
My Recommendation
Pick this if you want a compact, flexible air fry oven with a handy Reheat and Bagel mode. In the ninja air fryer 8 in 1 vs 9 in 1 decision, this is the simple, everyday choice for smaller households.
Is Ninja DT202BK Foodi 8-in-1 XL Pro Air Fry Oven Good?
Yes. It’s ideal if you need a powerful, large-capacity air fry oven. It suits families and batch cooking.
I cooked two sheet-pan meals at once, which saved my evening. The 1800W power gave me fast browning.
I also used it for a big chicken and veggies. It handled the load without hot spots.
What Makes It Stand Out / Key Features
- 8 cooking functions in an XL Pro oven
- 1800 Watts for strong, even heating
- Large countertop convection and digital toaster oven
- Designed for bigger batches and sheet-pan meals
- Two-level cooking potential with spacious interior
What I Like
- Big capacity for family meals
- Fast preheat and crisp results
- Consistent browning on fries and chicken
- Solid build with clear controls
- Makes meal prep and batching easier
What Could Be Better
- Takes more counter space than compact models
- Heavier to move or clean
- Learning curve for perfect rack placement
- 8 modes only; lacks the 9th preset
- May draw more power due to 1800W
My Recommendation
Choose this if you cook for a crowd or love sheet-pan dinners. In the ninja air fryer 8 in 1 vs 9 in 1 matchup, this is the power-and-capacity winner.
ninja air fryer 8 in 1 vs 9 in 1: Side-by-Side Test
I tested both for everyday meals. I compared functions, size, speed, and ease of use. Here’s how the ninja air fryer 8 in 1 vs 9 in 1 battle played out for me.
Cooking Functions: Which One Does More?
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Total modes | 9 | 8 |
| Air Fry | Yes | Yes |
| Reheat | Yes | Depends on preset grouping |
| Bagel | Yes | Varies by model settings |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 9/10 | 8-in-1 – 8/10
Summary: The 9-in-1 wins on sheer preset variety.
Capacity and Size: Who Feeds More People?
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Interior space | Compact | XL, two-level potential |
| Family meals | Best for 1–3 people | Great for 3–6 people |
| Sheet-pan cooking | Limited | Strong |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 7/10 | 8-in-1 – 9.5/10
Summary: The 8-in-1 XL Pro is the capacity leader.
Power and Heating: How Fast and Even?
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Wattage | Not specified | 1800W |
| Even browning | Good | Very good |
| High-heat sear | Moderate | Strong |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 7.5/10 | 8-in-1 – 9/10
Summary: The 8-in-1’s 1800W gives it the heat edge.
Speed and Preheat: Dinner on the Clock
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Preheat time | Fast for a compact oven | Fast for XL size |
| Fries to crisp | Quick | Quick and even |
| Multi-tray speed | Limited | Better |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 8/10 | 8-in-1 – 8.5/10
Summary: Both are quick; XL holds speed under larger loads.
Controls and Ease of Use: Which Is Simpler?
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Preset clarity | Very clear | Clear |
| Learning curve | Low | Moderate |
| Daily toast/bagel | Excellent | Good |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 9/10 | 8-in-1 – 8/10
Summary: The 9-in-1 is easier for quick daily tasks.
Footprint and Storage: Small Kitchen Fit
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Counter space | Smaller footprint | Larger footprint |
| Weight | Lighter | Heavier |
| Under-cabinet fit | Easier | Needs space |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 9/10 | 8-in-1 – 7/10
Summary: The 9-in-1 wins for tight spaces.
Cleaning and Maintenance: After-Dinner Cleanup
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Crumb/oil management | Simple | Simple but larger |
| Tray size | Smaller trays to wash | Bigger trays to wash |
| Interior reach | Easy | Deeper reach |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 8.5/10 | 8-in-1 – 7.5/10
Summary: The 9-in-1 is easier to clean due to size.
Noise and Build Quality: Day-to-Day Feel
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Fan noise | Moderate | Moderate |
| Exterior finish | Stainless look | Black finish |
| Door/rack feel | Solid | Solid |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 8/10 | 8-in-1 – 8/10
Summary: Both feel sturdy and sound similar.
Value and Use Cases: Who Gets More for the Money?
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Small homes, quick snacks | Families, batch cooks |
| Function-to-price | High for everyday use | High for capacity |
| Long-term fit | Great for light duty | Great for heavy duty |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 8.5/10 | 8-in-1 – 8.5/10
Summary: Value ties; pick based on size needs.
Accessories and Presets: What’s in the Box?
| Category | 9-in-1 Digital Oven | DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Included trays/racks | Varies | Varies (often more/larger) |
| Preset richness | Very good | Good |
| Multi-level cooking | Limited | Stronger |
Rating: 9-in-1 – 8/10 | 8-in-1 – 8.5/10
Summary: The 8-in-1 tends to include larger, more versatile hardware.
Final Verdict: Which Should You Buy?
If you want simple presets, smaller size, and a friendly control layout, the 9-in-1 Digital Oven fits best. It shines for toast, bagels, fries, and quick reheat. In the ninja air fryer 8 in 1 vs 9 in 1 debate, this is the no-fuss pick.
If you need power and room for family meals, the Ninja DT202BK 8-in-1 XL Pro Air Fry Oven is the smarter choice. It handles two-tray meals and bigger proteins with even heat.
Bottom line: small kitchen and daily snacks—go 9-in-1. Bigger meals and batch cooking—go 8-in-1.
FAQs Of ninja air fryer 8 in 1 vs 9 in 1
Which cooks faster in real life?
Both are quick. The 8-in-1’s 1800W helps with larger loads. For single servings, the 9-in-1 feels just as fast.
Which is better for families?
The 8-in-1 XL Pro. It offers more space and better two-level cooking for full dinners.
Does the 9-in-1 have unique modes?
Yes. It includes handy presets like Bagel and Reheat that the 8-in-1 may group differently.
Which one saves more counter space?
The 9-in-1. It’s easier to fit under cabinets and move around.
What’s the best overall pick in ninja air fryer 8 in 1 vs 9 in 1?
For capacity and power, choose the 8-in-1 XL Pro. For compact convenience and extra presets, choose the 9-in-1.
